How to Have the 'No Gifts' Talk with Family
Filed under: Family Finances, Shopping, Holidays
My brother and I were having lunch recently when the talk turned to the holidays. Over bowls of soup we discussed our current financial situations and mutually decided that we won't buy each other presents this year. Instead, we decided we'd rather focus on different goals - saving to buy a house and growing a new business.
For us, it was a simple conversation and it wasn't awkward because we both had already individually come to the same conclusion. However, it's not the easiest conversation to have with other family members or even friends. So if you've decided not to go the gift route this year, how do you break the news to your family and friends? Psychologist Dr. Michal Regev suggests that before you have the discussion with friends and family, you have the discussion with yourself. She says, "Is it coming from a 'poor me' perspective or is it coming from a different perspective? Before opening up the discussion with others, you need to clarify how you feel about not giving gifts."
Instead of coming from the angle of not being able to afford gifts, Regev suggests approaching the decision positively. "Change in life can be taken as a crisis or an opportunity," she says. "Tell yourself that this is an opportunity to do something different."
However, Regev does point out that not buying gifts and not doing anything in its place doesn't work. "People need to do something. You need that alternative gesture. Have an open discussion and find out another way to show your care and love." For example, a patient of hers who was a single mother had moved five years ago and couldn't afford gifts. Instead, she went and volunteered at a soup kitchen. She got certificates from the soup kitchen saying she had volunteered for her family. The family was so touched it has become an annual tradition.
Regev isn't suggesting you volunteer at a soup kitchen, but she does suggest that you consider alternative gifts that don't cost money. She says, "Do a beautiful card where you tell them how much they mean to you. Go over a day early and ask what they need help with. You should do something else that's meaningful."














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-07-2010 @ 5:56AM
Thomas said...
I stopped exchanging gifts with all adults in the family and refused to accept gifts from them...they didn't like it at first, but now are glad we aren't giving each other gifts that merely run up our charge accounts. I nstead I give more money to charities like the homeless mission here and underpriveliged kids. This was 10 years ago.
Reply
11-07-2010 @ 6:49PM
Dmom said...
We've stopped giving gifts to adults in my family and my husbands family. In my family we've changed this out with time instead of gifts and we make a point each year to get together for a nice dinner with just us. No other friends or family, just immediate family.
We also exchange names of kids in my husbands family so we only have to buy two gifts instead of nine. We have a budget for that gift as well that has dwindled from $100 to $40 over the last ten years. That way we're able to give something that is actually useful to the person rather than a $20 toy they'll never use again after a month.
If you can't or don't want to give a gift, give time instead. Take that person our for lunch, or do a nice dinner at your house for them and really take the time to connect and enjoy the season!!
Reply
11-08-2010 @ 8:00AM
melanie said...
In my extended family it was a no brainer... The gifts are for the kids. We even exchanged names and buy one gift for each child(generally the ones under 18, the older teens and young adults now do their own exchange). You spend a bit more on one gift(or two since I have two kids), but the kids all get a nice gift and overall it is cheaper than buying many cheap gifts... Last year me and my siblings/spouces only bought for one person, everyone got a gift without buying for everyone. We all bought for mom and dad, but that is okay, because my parents are always there to help us out and tend to spoil the kids...
James family now does an optional secret santa game for the adults and older teens. It is a great idea!.. Recently they also started a gift echange because once young families start having kids it gets expencive to buy for everyone.
I like it because it removes the obligation to spend tons of money on gifts for extended family. We get together and enjoy a nice meal and the kids get a gift.
For me I like to spend a nice day with family and freinds. Isn't that the meaning of Christmas anyway?
A gift extchange (everyone buys one gift for one person) is a nice alternative to an all or nothing approch that will probably be popular with everyone!
Reply